Beef Buzz Podcast

Ethan Lane Discusses MCOOL, Beef Labeling and Prop 12 Concerns

September 25th, 2026 09:00am
Ethan Lane Discusses MCOOL, Beef Labeling and Prop 12 Concerns
Beef Buzz Podcast
Ethan Lane Discusses MCOOL, Beef Labeling and Prop 12 Concerns
00:00:00
00:00:00
In today’s Beef Buzz, senior farm and ranch broadcaster Ron Hays features comments from Ethan Lane, senior vice president for governmental affairs for the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association, following a National Association of Farm Broadcasters webinar. Lane discussed the ongoing push for mandatory country of origin labeling and concerns about outside groups influencing livestock policy through major spending. Part one can be found here.

Mandatory Country of Origin Labeling

Lane said mandatory country of origin labeling, or MCOOL, could add costs for both cattle producers and consumers without necessarily increasing demand for U.S. beef. “The logic of pushing mandatory country of origin labeling in an environment where producers are complaining about high input costs and high cost to produce that product, at the same time that everyone is focused on lowering consumer prices, MCOOL would do two things right away,” Lane said. “It would raise costs for producers to comply with it, and it would raise the price of our product for consumers at the store. What it wouldn't do is drive demand.”

Lane pointed to recent research from Kansas State University that examined what consumers consider when purchasing beef. “Consumers buy on price and quality, and they're matching those two up right now when they go to the store,” Lane said.

He said the current conversation surrounding MCOOL has also been influenced by additional lean beef trim entering the U.S. supply chain through tariff agreements. “We know we need that lean trim to make our ground beef supply and to meet those needs across the supply chain,” Lane said. “We raise heavily marbled cattle in this country. We raise cattle that are designed to produce that Prime New York strip that I enjoyed at a steakhouse in Kansas City earlier this week. What doesn't come off that animal is 80/20 or 90/10, right? And so we need those sources of lean trim.”

Lane said the beef industry needs to consider how additional supplies of imported trim fit into the overall supply chain. “When you start artificially trying to juice those into the supply chain without maybe understanding how they match up, right? Who's asking for it, or if anyone is asking for more of it, it starts to have these kinds of effects,” Lane said.

Voluntary Product of USA Label

Instead of mandatory labeling, Lane pointed to USDA’s voluntary Product of USA labeling program as an alternative. “The voluntary Product of USA label fixes that labeling issue that consumers and producers were concerned about,” Lane said.

He said the program can give consumers more information while allowing producers to pursue premiums through branded beef programs. “We've been proud to work on closing that loophole. We've been pleased that USDA has pushed that program,” Lane said. “We feel like that is a far better alternative as we look for ways to make sure that we're leaning into the premiums and the branded products and the things that are truly generating some premiums for our producers, rather than just saddling them with more cost.”

Concerns Over Prop 12 Advocacy

Lane also discussed Proposition 12 and broader efforts by animal rights and activist organizations to influence livestock policy.

He questioned where the funding behind some of those advocacy efforts is coming from, particularly when organizations describe themselves as representing small farmers. “How does an initiative being led by groups like the American Meat Producers Association, who claim to represent small farmers or Farm Action for that matter, that spent 30 million dollars opposing the Save Our Bacon Act in June alone,” Lane said.

Lane questioned how organizations representing a relatively small portion of agri

Copy episode link

Ron salutes our daily email sponsors!

Upcoming Events

November

S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30          

Visitor Polls

Do you like the new website?
Add a Comment
(Fields are Optional)

Your email address is never published.